Assays, stage response, and recycle routing
The grinding product supplies 100 dry t/h to a rougher–cleaner flotation circuit. It contains 15 dry t/h valuable mineral V and 85 dry t/h gangue G. These are mineral masses on a dry basis. An elemental assay would require a separate conversion from mineralogy to payable element. The incoming water rate is 100 t/h, and a further 45 t/h dilution water joins the rougher inlet before cleaner recycle. Rougher concentrate feeds the cleaner. Cleaner concentrate is final product, cleaner tailings recycle to the rougher, and rougher tailings go to water recovery.
Use three conserved channels V, G and W. A stage coefficient pᵢ means the fraction of that channel's incoming material reporting to the named stage concentrate. Let rᵢ be rougher recovery and cᵢ cleaner recovery. The instructional coefficients are effective local splits for a single ore and operating condition. Stage water recovery is a volumetric or mass fraction when density is held constant. In this example it is a mass fraction and the constant density of water is 1.00 t/m³.
| Channel | External input (t/h) | Rougher recovery r | Cleaner recovery c |
|---|---|---|---|
| Valuable mineral V | 15 | 0.92 | 0.90 |
| Gangue G | 85 | 0.12 | 0.15 |
| Water W | 145 | 0.20 | 0.35 |
Several mechanisms affect the solids splits. Mineral liberation and surface condition control opportunities for collection. Water reporting to froth can entrain suspended particles, especially fines. A single gangue recovery cannot distinguish true flotation of hydrophobic minerals, entrainment, or poorly liberated composites. Mineral class, size and liberation can be tracked as additional channels when data support their coefficients. Without internal and size-resolved data, fitted mechanisms can trade off while leaving final grade and recovery unchanged. Savassi et al., 1998, industrial entrainment model00003-X)
Direct solution by channel
Let Fᵢ be external input and Xᵢ total rougher feed including recycle. Rougher concentrate is Yᵢ = rᵢXᵢ. Cleaner tailings are Tᵢ = (1 − cᵢ)Yᵢ, so Xᵢ = Fᵢ + Tᵢ. Final concentrate is Cᵢ and rougher tailings are Qᵢ.
The sum follows because cᵢrᵢ + 1 − rᵢ = 1 − rᵢ(1 − cᵢ). The denominator is the portion that exits the circuit on a given pass. Equivalently, the eventual recovery to final concentrate is rᵢcᵢ multiplied by 1 + aᵢ + aᵢ² + …, where aᵢ = rᵢ(1 − cᵢ) is the fraction returned on each pass. For valuable mineral, aᵥ = 0.092. Thus rougher feed is 15/0.908 = 16.5198 t/h, and final valuable mineral is 0.90 × 0.92 × 16.5198 = 13.6784 t/h. For water, a(W) = 0.13, so rougher feed water is 145/0.87 = 166.6667 t/h.
| Stream | V (t/h) | G (t/h) | Total dry solids (t/h) | Water (t/h) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| External feed with dilution | 15.0000 | 85.0000 | 100.0000 | 145.0000 |
| Rougher feed | 16.5198 | 94.6548 | 111.1746 | 166.6667 |
| Rougher concentrate and cleaner feed | 15.1982 | 11.3586 | 26.5568 | 33.3333 |
| Cleaner tailings recycle | 1.5198 | 9.6548 | 11.1746 | 21.6667 |
| Final concentrate | 13.6784 | 1.7038 | 15.3822 | 11.6667 |
| Rougher tailings | 1.3216 | 83.2962 | 84.6178 | 133.3333 |
Dry concentrate mass yield is 15.3822%, valuable mineral grade is 88.924%, and valuable recovery is 91.189%. Final water recovery is 11.6667/145 = 8.046% on external feed water. Compute all mass yields and grades from consistent channels. Here final concentrate is 56.87% dry solids by wet mass, so valuable mineral is only about 50.57% of wet concentrate when expressed on that different basis. Water recovery to rougher concentrate remains 20% relative to gross rougher feed. The solids and water balances independently close at the overall boundary. This chapter passes the rougher tailings stream unchanged to the next case.
Comparing grade, recovery, and circuit duty
At a tighter cleaner setting cᵥ = 0.85 and c(G) = 0.10, preserve rougher coefficients, water splits and feed for the comparison. Eventual valuable recovery becomes 0.92 × 0.85/[1 − 0.92 × 0.15] = 90.719%, with 13.6079 t/h valuable mineral in the final concentrate. Gangue in final concentrate becomes 1.1435 t/h. Concentrate grade increases to 92.248%, and final dry product falls to 14.7514 t/h. Cleaner tailings solids recycle increases from 11.1746 to 12.6929 t/h. If the plant target calls for at least 90% dry valuable mineral grade and 90% recovery, the tighter setting meets both in this synthetic case. Water and entrainment often move together, so the independent water splits here describe a sensitivity calculation. They do not establish that a real operating change would preserve the same water circuit.
Another sensitivity changes rougher gangue recovery from 12% to 15% at the initial cleaner setting. The final concentrate now carries 2.1920 t/h gangue and is 86.188% valuable mineral, with the same modeled valuable recovery. Final gangue response is stronger than a single pass would suggest, because rougher gangue that reports to cleaner tailings can be processed repeatedly. For fixed cleaner split c, eventual fraction to final concentrate is R = cr/[1 − r(1 − c)]. Differentiation gives ∂R/∂r = c/[1 − r(1 − c)]². This expression measures local sensitivity to a fitted stage split. It says nothing about how plant controls change r without a further physical or empirical relationship.
Bulk coefficients can also hide a grind change. Suppose 80% of incoming valuable mineral lies in classes with 95% rougher recovery and 20% in classes with 80%. The feed-weighted rougher recovery is 92% on that feed. If the second group grows to 35%, the fresh-feed-weighted value falls to 89.75%. However, with cleaner recovery 90% for each class, their overall recoveries are 0.95 × 0.90/0.905 = 94.475% and 0.80 × 0.90/0.92 = 78.261%. Applying them to the new fresh mixture gives 88.800% valuable recovery. Changes in grind and mineral liberation can propagate even when stage settings and the total dry rate stay fixed. A coupled study should preserve the size and mineral basis between grinding and concentration.
Evidence for a circuit decision
Calibrate flotation response using ore domains and collection protocols relevant to the plant. Record the rougher and cleaner mass pull, water recovery, concentrate grade and internal return. If samples agree only after a large adjustment to the mass or mineral balance, document which measurement drives the correction and quantify its uncertainty. A test with no cleaner return validates an open-circuit split on its own feed. It does not test enrichment of poorly floating or entrained populations in the closed circuit. Locked-cycle or plant surveys across independent conditions characterize the internal routing and help distinguish mechanism from compensation in fitted splits.
For an operating choice, compare grade and valuable recovery simultaneously and keep water carryover, dry product rate, reagent and gas conditions, and recycle demand in the accounting. Product quality may govern the choice even where recovered tonnes remain similar. The next case tests whether the water leaving both tails and concentrate permits the same dilution and mill feed density during reclaim interruptions.
Exercises with answers
- What would valuable recovery be if cleaner tailings were discarded on the base coefficients? Answer. 0.92 × 0.90 = 82.8% of fresh valuable mineral, or 12.42 t/h in final product. With recycle the result is 91.189%, with higher rougher duty.
- Compute valuable mineral grade of base rougher tailings on a dry basis. Answer. 1.321586/84.617800 = 1.562%.
- If W to the rougher from outside the flotation loop increases by 10 t/h and splits remain fixed, how much extra water reaches tailings? Answer. The incremental rougher water feed is 10/0.87 = 11.4943 t/h. Of that, 80% or 9.1954 t/h reaches rougher tailings and 0.8046 t/h exits with final concentrate.
- At fixed base valuable mineral splits, what is the maximum final gangue flow consistent with 90% dry valuable mineral grade? Answer. 13.6784 × (1/0.90 − 1) = 1.5198 t/h. Base gangue flow of 1.7038 t/h exceeds that condition.
